How We Review Products
Our scoring method, what we can and cannot verify, and exactly how we make money.
Last updated
Most supplement reviews online are affiliate pages wearing a lab coat. We make money the same way they do, through commissions, so the only thing that separates us is whether the method is stated plainly enough for you to check it against what we actually publish.
Here it is.
How we make money
We earn a commission when a reader buys through a link on this site. That is our entire revenue model. There is no advertising, no sponsored placement, and no arrangement where a company pays for coverage or for a particular score.
What that means practically: we have a financial interest in you clicking. You should read everything here with that in mind, which is why the disclosure appears on every page that carries a link rather than only in the footer.
What it does not mean: nobody buys a score. Commission rates vary between products, and we do not weight our scoring by them. You can check this: the lower-scored products on this site are frequently the ones with higher payouts.
What we can actually verify
We are not a laboratory. We do not run assays, we do not test purity, and we cannot confirm that what is in a bottle matches the label. Anyone claiming otherwise about a mass-market supplement, without publishing the certificate of analysis, is overstating what they did.
What we can do is trace claims. For each product we:
- Take each specific claim the marketing makes.
- Look for published human research on the active ingredient at a comparable dose.
- Check whether the dose in the product is within range of what was studied.
- Note where the research is animal-only, industry-funded, or absent.
Point four is where most products come apart. It is very common to find an ingredient with genuine research behind it, included at a fraction of the studied dose.
Step three is published in full. Every dose we have read off a label, against the amount the research used, is in the dose gap, with the source of each comparison and the date we checked it. Twelve of the twenty products we cover publish no supplement facts panel at all, which is where that table starts.
The scoring
Each review scores four criteria out of five. The overall figure is their average, unweighted, so you can recompute it if you weight them differently.
Evidence quality. Is there human research on these ingredients, at these doses? Randomised trials score higher than observational work, which scores higher than mechanistic or animal data.
Formulation. Are the doses meaningful, or is this a long ingredient list at token quantities? Is the form of each ingredient one the body can use?
Value. Cost per day against what comparable ingredients cost separately. Subscription terms and refund policy count here.
Transparency. Is the full formulation disclosed with per-ingredient doses, or hidden behind a proprietary blend? Are the cited studies real, and do they say what the marketing claims they say?
A product can score well on formulation and badly overall. That combination is common and usually means the ingredients are fine and the price is not.
What a score is not
A score is our reading of the available evidence at the time of writing. It is not medical advice, it is not a prediction of what will happen to you, and it is not a claim that any product treats a condition.
Supplements are regulated as food, not medicine. That means nobody has verified that they work before they went on sale, and the manufacturer is not permitted to claim they treat a disease. When you see a supplement page implying otherwise, that is a regulatory violation, and it is a reasonable signal about the rest of the operation.
When we change a review
We revisit reviews when new research is published, when a formulation changes, or when a reader points out something we got wrong. Updated reviews carry the revision date at the top.
If you think something here is wrong, tell us. Corrections are the cheapest thing we can do to be worth reading, so get in touch.
